Beautifully Transparent: Dostoevsky’s Theodicy in The Tree of Life
Terrence Malick’s film, The Tree of Life, is an attempt to answer this question: how does one reconcile tragedy and suffering with the idea of a loving God? The mistake most interpretations and critiques make with respect to exegeting how the film attempts to answer this question is a classic one: losing the forest for the trees. As we will see, by understanding the undisclosed source material of the film, the answer cannot come in the form of a syllogism or series of propositions. This essay will not be interpreting The Tree of Life but rather demonstrating what it relies on for a foundation, thereby extracting important information about how to view the film. The Tree of Life has been called empty, cliché, and pretentious. One thing, however, that nobody argues with is that The Tree of Life is filled with beauty. What gave rise to this beauty, to Malick’s ultimate theodicy, and serves as the film’s unofficial foundation is Fyodor Dostoevsky’s 19th-century classic: The Brothers Karamazov. The novel provided chunks of material for the film in the form of the most precious and collective-consciousness-tapping monologues, a philosophical dialectic for it to fit into, and a vision for the cinematography. Dostoevsky spent his life attempting to answer the same question that The Tree of Life attempts to answer, and The Brothers Karamazov can be seen, in toto, as his answer. The same can be said for Malick’s magnum opus. To many viewers, and indeed to many critics (as will be shown), The Tree of Life is impenetrable. However, once the source material is understood, Malick’s ambiguous poetic film becomes beautifully transparent.
The Tree of Life is about grief, suffering, death, and how to reconcile tragedy with the glory and ultimate goodness of God. We see this all through the prism of a family: a husband (Mr. O’Brien), a wife (Mrs. O’Brien), and three brothers (Jack, R.L., and Steve). Critics of the film often cite its “experimental” and languid approach as a hindrance to being able to grasp its message. David Denby, a critic for The New Yorker, who elsewhere calls the film “insufferable: interminable, madly repetitive, vague, humorless, grandiose” (Denby, 2011), concedes, after apparent reflection, that that impression does not hold water: “That impression, however, turns out to be false” (Denby, 2011). Denby attributes his revised evaluation to the family drama that regains the film’s footing. But the family serves only as a message-carrier for the film’s deeper meaning. Denby’s sense is correct, but he appears unable to locate the true source of the film’s revivification. What Denby senses but cannot name is Dostoevsky’s own theodicy showing through, legible once one knows where to look. Denby points out for us another crucial misunderstanding that he hand-waves instead of investigates: his first reaction to the film’s opening: “The beginning is not promising: a quotation from Job, whispered prayers to God, undulating gaseous colors, indefinite in shape, indeterminate in meaning” (Denby, 2011). The Job quotation Denby finds indeterminate is, as this essay will show, anything but; its meaning is supplied in full and explicit detail by Zosima’s own exegesis of that very biblical passage in The Brothers Karamazov. And The Tree of Life offers its own exegesis of sorts, but not in exposition, as it is a film and not a novel and Terrence Malick is not Fyodor Dostoevsky; indeed, without the Job quotation, the film would be incoherent. Another critic, Shlomo Schwartzberg (2011), grants that Malick “has a movie director’s eye” but argues the film’s imagery is ultimately “empty,” a mere stand-in for the depth its characters lack. This is a grave misreading. Schwartzberg’s critique assumes the imagery is doing nothing but looking pretty. Read against Zosima’s theology, however, the creation sequence and indeed the cinematography on the whole are not at all empty; they are the very answer Malick is offering his audience, and it is Dostoevsky’s novel’s own claim that the whole physical world is a form of divine instruction. Dostoevsky’s novel as a whole can be taken as a response to the argument from evil, and given the deep connections we see between novel and film, we can also take Malick’s movie, in its wholeness, as an argument for God’s glory, one that presents its theodicy precisely through the beauty Schwartzberg calls “empty.” It may be useful to recall here Marshall McLuhan’s famous phrase “the medium is the message” (McLuhan, 1964, p. 7) to help one to envision Malick’s film as a whole as his theodicy. When we look into The Brothers Karamazov, any sort of mystique that The Tree of Life holds dissolves, because Dostoevsky hides nothing in his prose: there, all is laid bare. The 19th-century classic also revolves around three brothers (Alexei, Ivan and Dimitri Karamazov) and their father (Fyodor Karamazov). The critics who call The Tree of Life bad, impenetrable, pretentious, self-indulgent and so on are missing not only the point of why the film was made, but of where it comes from. This is crucial. It is certainly a lot to ask an audience to engage not only with a feature-length film, but a biblically-sized novel in order to completely understand a message. However, such is the case with The Tree of Life. What the critics appear to misunderstand is that the film comes from and is a reflection on Dostoevsky’s novel. Therefore, as has been mentioned, understanding the connection between the film and the novel is an important part of understanding the film in its fullness. In some sense, it is an oblique presentation of the work that precedes it.
The most wonderful scene in the entire film, the essence of the whole thing in beauty and substance, is not the sequence that epically depicts the grand creation of the universe (which, evidently, most critics seem to entirely miss the point of), but Brad Pitt’s softly delivered monologue. This scene is our entry point into first understanding how precisely the film borrowed from the novel: “I wanted to be loved because I was great; a big man. I'm nothing. Look at the glory around us; trees, birds. I lived in shame. I dishonoured it all and didn't notice the glory. I'm a foolish man” (Malick, 2011). Dostoevsky’s writing is courageous and full of introspection that successfully reaches into the depths of what it means to be human. Interestingly, this is something that critics seem to find lacking in Malick’s film. However, that also makes it all the more understandable why Malick pulled from the 900-page masterpiece to help him in the creation of what would become his magnum opus. Dostoevsky provided the humanness that Malick so needed as a foundation. Malick found the above monologue almost in its entirety in the chapter “From the Life . . . of the Elder Zosima . . .” (Dostoevsky, 1880/1990, p. 304). In the chapter, the Elder is recounting the unfolding of his early childhood with his mother and brother, Markel, an atheist who swore and laughed at God. Markel refused his mother’s offers to go to liturgy, to pray, or to take at all seriously the notion of God. However, when he finds out that he is sick and that he will soon die, things change. He “…started speaking to everyone in unexpected and endearing ways…” (Dostoevsky, 1880/1990, p. 306): “Dear mother, heart of my heart…my joyful one…” (Dostoevsky, 1880/1990, p. 306). As the Elder’s recollection continues, a picture is painted for us in which Markel is in his room, looking out his window to see a garden. He sees that “the spring buds were already swelling on the branches, the early birds arrived, chattering, singing through his windows” (Dostoevsky, 1880/1990, p. 307). In this single line alone, we can see The Tree of Life starting to be born. Markel goes on to make a most sublime confession, and we can see the source material for Malick’s film overflowing:
And suddenly, looking at them and admiring them, he began to ask their forgiveness, too: “Birds of God, joyful birds, you, too, must forgive me, because I have also sinned before you.” None of us could understand it then, but he was weeping with joy: “Yes,” he said, “there was so much of God’s glory around me: birds, trees, meadows, sky, and I alone lived in shame, I alone dishonoured everything, and did not notice the beauty and glory of it all.” (Dostoevsky, 1880/1990, p. 307)
The dialogue was taken almost verbatim to help create the most touching and beautiful sequence in the film. Dostoevsky’s prose here is full of imagery, which, if one tried to put into cinematic visuals, would conceivably end up with some version of The Tree of Life. The mother, Mrs. O’Brien, has a monologue of similar cadence to the father’s. She says, “Help each other. Love every one, every leaf, every ray of light. Forgive” (Malick, 2011). It is quite clear that this passage also has its foundation in The Brothers Karamazov:
Love all of God’s creation, both the whole of it and every grain of sand. Love every leaf, every ray of God’s light. Love animals, love plants, love each thing. If you love each thing, you will perceive the mystery of God in things. (Dostoevsky, 1880/1990, p. 338)
Malick has distilled Dostoevsky into The Tree of Life. He has taken dialogue nearly verbatim, but it is obvious how much more of the novel is in the very fabric of the film. It informs the film on every level. We can see the beginning of the impact that Dostoevsky’s prose had on the visuals that Malick creates, which serves the function of grace and beauty not only within the film but also for the viewer: the visuals end up being Malick’s theodicy. Malick’s theodicy grows out of the Book of Job from the Old Testament. The film opens with a compressed quote from Job, the same one that David Denby thought was indeterminate and empty: "Where were you when I laid the foundation of the earth ... when the morning stars sang together?” (English Standard Version Bible, 2001, Job 38:4, 7). This quote sets the stage for the film’s primary theme of suffering and tragedy as told through the story of a family losing a child, and makes it known from the outset that Malick is interested in theodicy, and in one’s ability to persevere in the face of tragedy and death. The quote indicates to the audience that what follows is a response and a justification. We learn more about the significance of why Malick uses Job from Dostoevsky, who also goes to the Book of Job, just two pages after Markel’s revelation about life and God. Father Zosima, still recounting his childhood, is talking about his first understanding in church, and it came from a reading from the Book of Job:
Oh, Lord, one thinks, “but how could he so love those new ones, when his former children are no more, when he hast lost them? Remembering them, was it possible for him to be fully happy, as he had been before, with the new ones, however dear they might be to him?” But it is possible, it is possible: old grief, by a great mystery of human life, gradually passes into quiet, tender joy; instead of young, ebullient blood comes a mild, serene old age: I bless the sun’s rising each day and my heart sings to it as before, but now, I love its setting even more, its long slanting rays, and with them quiet, mild, tender memories, dear images from the whole of a long and blessed life–and over all is God’s truth, moving, reconciling, all-forgiving! (Dostoevsky, 1880/1990, pp. 309–310)
This passage from Dostoevsky’s novel is the best summary of The Tree of Life that exists. It is also a good exegesis of the Book of Job, albeit a personal and heartfelt one. Consider that if Malick took, nearly word for word, a passage just before this one, it is fair to assume that this exposition on Job deeply informed the film as well, albeit less obvious and explicit than Markel’s confession, but in a way that is philosophically foundational to the film. After all, what Malick is trying to do in the film is reconcile tragedy and glory, sadness and joy. As previously mentioned, the film itself, as an object of the audience’s perception, is Malick’s theodicy. It is part of Malick’s answer to Dostoevsky’s devastating question, and the most famous part of The Brothers Karamazov, which we will soon discuss in more depth.
In the passage directly above, we see more visuals from Malick’s film present and budding in the prose, as if it were a treatment for the visual palette of the film. It has built on the earlier excerpt of Markel’s monologue, which is steeped in the beauty, glory, and pristine quality held by nature as a reminder of God’s ultimate grace and goodness and how easy it can be to lose sight of that as a human plagued by tragedy and grief, being, as the Apostle Paul says, a "slave of sin” (English Standard Version Bible, 2001, Romans 6:20) as both Markel and Mr. O’Brien most certainly are. This all begins to be inextricably linked: the visuals, the confession, Job, suffering, grief, the problem of evil, the prose: the novel and the film. If we pull out one line from the above passage, we can see even more clearly where Malick found his visual inspiration, which is so focused on the sun in its glory and beauty and purity: “I bless the sun’s rising each day…its long slanting rays, and with them quiet, mild, tender memories, dear images…and over all is God’s truth…” (Dostoevsky, 1880/1990, p. 310). Remember that this is the elder Zosima speaking, the book’s primary figure of goodness and truth and Dostoevsky’s only hope at answering his own devastating question posed just pages earlier in the novel. This phrase puts the film’s use of sunlight into a distinct category and illuminates its metaphorical power in a new way. What was once ambiguous filmic poetry becomes very clear and readable. Cinematographically, there comes yet another clear-as-day explanation for one of Malick’s other obsessions in the film: vertical camera movement always reaching for heights, through trees and smoke and windows toward the sun and sky:
I remember how, even before I learned to read, a certain spiritual perception visited me for the first time, when I was just eight years old…remembering it now, I seem to see again the incense rising from the censer and quietly ascending upwards, and from above, through a narrow window in the cupola, God’s rays pouring down upon us…and the incense rising up to them in waves, as if dissolving into them. (Dostoevsky, 1880/1990, p. 308)
Of course, Dostoevsky is not the only influence present in The Tree of Life, and not by a long shot is he the only influence on Terrence Malick. It is well known that Malick was deeply influenced by Martin Heidegger, because he not only studied him at Harvard and Magdalen College, but he translated Heidegger’s The Essence of Reasons in 1969. Put very briefly, Malick’s Heideggerian-influenced philosophy informs his use of nature and objects cinematographically: the sense of Being discloses itself by way of attentiveness to nature. This is very well known:
We might regard The Tree of Life as a virtuosic translation of the thought of origins in The Essence of Reasons into the language of cinema. By constructing a cinematic idiom that radically alters the hermetic terminology of Heideggerian philosophy and the generic tropes of blockbuster movies, Malick’s Tree of Life both transmits and transforms the thematization of origin world, and transcendence at issue in Heidegger’s The Essence of reasons. (Hay, 2014)
Without doubt, Heidegger has his influence over the works of Terrence Malick. However, read The Brothers Karamazov, and it becomes clear that if Malick owes anyone a debt for The Tree of Life, it is payable to Dostoevsky. The Heideggerian influence occurs at such a level of depth, philosophically speaking, that it is unreachable to most. Never mind that if one considers The Tree of Life to be impenetrable, then the works of Martin Heidegger may as well be written in a language lost to most of humankind. If Malick gets his philosophy of ontology from Heidegger, he gets his meaning from Dostoevsky. The Tree of Life impacts its audiences. This impact would not be possible without Dostoevsky’s influence, because there is no translation of any work by Heidegger that has the emotion that bursts forth from the pages of Dostoevsky’s novel. Indeed, Heidegger himself may be the first person to admit this. Malick is clearly aware of this, which is why he has borrowed Dostoevsky’s words. Indeed, if Malick were to transpose Heidegger’s words directly to the screen as he has done with Dostoevsky’s, the film would make even less sense to critics and audiences who already struggle to grasp it. Malick may be bringing Heidegger to the screen, but much less explicitly than how he is bringing Dostoevsky to the screen. In a way, Malick is updating and modernizing Dostoevsky’s novel, and introducing its themes to a new generation and in a new, if not secretive, way.
What precedes the chapter, “From the Life . . . of the Elder Zosima . . .” (Dostoevsky, 1880/1990, p. 304), is Dostoevsky’s own attempt (through his character, Ivan Karamazov) to crush any hope of reconciling with God (which is what one must do in order to answer to the harshest objection to a position one holds, which in this case is the true and actual existence of God, and in Dostoevsky’s case, Jesus Christ as he is known in the Russian Orthodox Church). This is the problem of evil that was referred to earlier. One of the great modern theologians and philosophers, David Bentley Hart, cites the problem of evil as the only legitimate and coherent argument atheists have against God (Closer to the Truth, 2019). In Dostoevsky’s novel, the argument is brought forth by Ivan Karamazov, an intellectual atheist who is willing to accept that God exists but refuses Him on the grounds of the great evil and tragedy present in the world. In a conversation with his brother, Alyosha, he explains that he simply cannot abide the world created by God, and he has decided therefore to “most respectfully return him the ticket” (Dostoevsky, 1880/1990, p. 261). He makes this decision primarily on the grounds of the suffering of children, which he goes into great and chilling detail about. He then goes on to recite a poem he chose not to write down but had memorized: “The Grand Inquisitor.” Anyone who has read The Brothers Karamazov has had to wrestle with Ivan’s poem. In it, Dostoevsky is levelling the most powerful argument against accepting God on God’s terms. It’s very difficult, if not impossible, to answer from a place of pure reason, which is why Dostoevsky himself shows the answer to the poem to be one of faith, intuition, and a gleaning of the scope of a cosmic drama that stretches from time immemorial into eternity. Malick alludes to Ivan’s arguments (in The Brothers Karamazov, Dostoevsky calls Ivan’s arguments his “Rebellion,” which is the name of the chapter that precedes “The Grand Inquisitor”) throughout his film by showing suffering in different forms to the audience through the eyes of the brothers. The Tree of Life is not meant to be a depressing film. In fact, it’s meant to be just the opposite: it’s meant to be one that shows an ultimate vision of a glorious and eternal reconciliation, despite any darkness or suffering or tragedy. The poem is too long to summarize or quote in short here, but as has already been mentioned, Ivan Karamazov spares no delicate person’s mind’s eye in his exposition. Horrors are recounted.
In the following pages of the novel, lies the clearest answer Dostoevsky attempts as a rejoinder to Ivan Karamazov’s dark and devastating poem–and it comes from the elder Zosima:
forgive my tears, for I love this book! Let him, the priest of God, weep too, and he will see how the hearts of his listeners will be shaken in response to him. Only a little, a tiny seed is needed: let him cast it into the soul of a simple man, and it will not die, it will live in his soul all his life, hiding there amidst the darkness, amidst the stench of his sins, as a bright point, as a great reminder. And there is no need, no need of much explaining and teaching, he will understand everything simply. (Dostoevsky, 1880/1990, p. 311)
In the final analysis, both works show us that there is only one question worth asking, because it answers all other questions, and this is the question that both men are concerned with in their respective masterworks of different mediums. That question is this: Does God exist, and if he does, will he save us from evil? The Tree of Life is itself an answer to this question when taken as a whole and cross-referenced with Dostoevsky’s novel. In the film, of course, at the very end, we witness the characters’ reconciliation in a sort of heaven. All tears are washed away, all suffering ostensibly forgotten. But Ivan Karamazov’s poem has a lingering power, and Ivan himself already addressed the question of eternity as an unsatisfying answer to the great evils that have been perpetrated against children. Terrence Malick has attempted to answer to Ivan Karamazov, to Fyodor Dostoevsky, and in the conclusion of The Tree of Life, his answer is quite clear: the promise of glory beyond a world of suffering is sufficient. That’s on the rational side. That’s the obvious answer: that all is made right in heaven. It is part of the answer, as it must be, but as it goes in philosophy that is perhaps necessary but not sufficient. For Malick’s complete theodicy, one must take the film in all at once, as if in a Dostoevskian flash.
References
Closer to the Truth. (2019, September 28). David Bentley Hart - Atheism’s best arguments? [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AQBfoneh97E
Denby, D. (2011, June 21). Terrence Malick’s insufferable masterpiece. The New Yorker. https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/terrence-malicks-insufferable-masterpiece
Dostoevsky, F. (1990). The brothers Karamazov (R. Pevear & L. Volokhonsky, Trans.). Farrar, Straus and Giroux. (Original work published 1880)
English Standard Version Bible. (2001). Crossway.
Hay, N. (2014). Cosmic mourning: The birth of transcendence in Terrence Malick’s Tree of Life. TRANS-, 18. https://doi.org/10.4000/trans.1065
Malick, T. (Director). (2011). The Tree of Life [Film]. Fox Searchlight Pictures.
McLuhan, M. (1964). Understanding media: The extensions of man. McGraw-Hill.
Schwartzberg, S. (2011, August 12). The fog of film: Terrence Malick’s The Tree of Life. Critics at Large. https://www.criticsatlarge.ca/2011/08/fog-of-film-terence-malicks-tree-of.html